Procurement Glossary
Carrier performance: measurement and evaluation of transport service provider performance
November 19, 2025
Carrier performance refers to the systematic evaluation and measurement of the performance of transport service providers in the logistics chain. This KPI enables buyers to objectively assess the quality and reliability of their logistics partners and make strategic decisions when selecting suppliers. Find out below how carrier performance is defined, which measurement methods exist and how you can successfully use this KPI in your procurement management.
Key Facts
- Carrier performance includes key figures such as punctuality, damage rate and cost efficiency of transport service providers
- Typical measured values are 95-99% delivery reliability for first-class carriers in the B2B sector
- The evaluation is usually carried out using scorecards with weighted KPIs for quality, time and costs
- Regular performance reviews enable continuous improvements to the logistics partnership
- Digital tracking systems and EDI integration significantly increase measurement accuracy
Contents
Definition and importance of carrier performance
Carrier Performance is a comprehensive evaluation system for the performance of transportation service providers and forms the basis for strategic logistics decisions.
Key aspects of carrier performance
The assessment covers several dimensions of transport performance. The focus is on time-related factors such as delivery reliability and transit times, supplemented by quality criteria such as damage rates and service quality.
- On-time delivery rate (degree of punctuality)
- Loss ratio and loss rate
- Cost efficiency and price transparency
- Communication quality and response time
Carrier performance vs. supplier performance
While Delivery Performance refers to the entire supplier performance, Carrier Performance focuses exclusively on transportation processing. This specialization enables a more precise evaluation of logistics services.
Importance of carrier performance in Procurement
For strategic Procurement , Carrier Performance forms the basis for supplier selection and development. The systematic evaluation supports negotiations and enables data-based decisions when optimizing the supply chain.
Measurement, database and calculation
The systematic recording of carrier performance requires structured measurement methods and reliable data sources for meaningful assessments.
Data acquisition and tracking systems
Modern tracking technologies form the basis for precise performance measurements. GPS-based systems record transport times in real time, while EDI interfaces enable automated data transfer.
- Automatic time stamping for collection and delivery
- Integration of Advance Shipping Notice systems
- Damage recording through digital documentation
KPI calculation and weighting
The calculation is based on weighted scorecards that take various performance dimensions into account. Typical weightings are 40% delivery reliability, 30% quality and 30% costs, depending on the company's requirements.
Benchmarking and comparative analyses
Regular benchmarks against market standards and competitor performance create transparency. Freight audit processes support the validation of measurement results and uncover optimization potential.
Tacto Intelligence
Combines deep procurement knowledge with the most powerful AI agents for strong Procurement.
KPIs and verification criteria
Meaningful KPIs form the basis for objective carrier performance evaluations and enable data-based decisions in transportation management.
Primary key performance indicators
The most important KPIs include time-related, qualitative and cost-related metrics. On-time delivery rate should be at least 95%, while the damage rate should be below 0.5%.
- Delivery reliability (on-time delivery): Target value 95-99%
- Damage rate: Maximum 0.5% of the shipment volume
- Cost deviation: Tolerance ±3% of the agreed tariff
- Response time for problems: Maximum 2 hours
Secondary evaluation criteria
Additional KPIs take service quality and communication into account. The quality of documentation and completeness of packing lists as well as compliance with dock appointments are included in the overall assessment.
Verification and documentation
Systematic documentation of all performance data creates transparency and traceability. Monthly performance reports and trend analyses support continuous improvement processes and contract negotiations with transport service providers.
Risks, dependencies and countermeasures
The evaluation of carrier performance entails various risks that can be minimized through systematic countermeasures.
Data quality and measurement inaccuracies
Incomplete or incorrect data can lead to incorrect performance evaluations. Manual data entry errors and system failures impair the informative value of the key figures.
- Implementation of redundant data acquisition systems
- Regular data validation and plausibility checks
- Training employees in correct data entry
One-sided KPI focus
Overemphasizing individual KPIs can lead to suboptimal results. Carriers could, for example, prioritize punctuality at the expense of transport quality, which leads to higher damage rates.
Dependence on carrier cooperation
Insufficient data provision on the part of transport service providers makes precise assessments difficult. 3PL partners must be obliged to transmit data transparently in order to enable reliable performance analyses.
.avif)
Practical example
An automotive supplier implements a comprehensive carrier performance system for its European transport routes. The company defines weighted KPIs: 40% delivery reliability, 25% damage rate, 20% cost efficiency and 15% communication quality. Monthly scorecards are used to evaluate three main carriers, with Carrier A identified as the preferred partner with 96% overall performance. The systematic evaluation leads to 15% cost savings and 20% fewer delivery delays.
- Implementation of automated tracking systems
- Monthly performance reviews with all carriers
- Development of improvement measures based on weak point analysis
Data and market trends on carrier performances
Digitalization and new technologies are fundamentally changing the measurement and evaluation of carrier performance and creating new opportunities for more precise analyses.
AI-supported performance analysis
Artificial intelligence is revolutionizing carrier evaluation through predictive analyses and automated anomaly detection. Machine learning algorithms identify patterns in transport data and predict performance trends.
- Predictive analytics for delivery delays
- Automatic risk assessment based on historical data
- Intelligent carrier recommendations for specific routes
Real-time visibility and IoT integration
Internet-of-Things sensors enable continuous monitoring of shipments and create complete transparency in the supply chain. This real-time data significantly improves the accuracy of performance measurements.
Sustainability as a performance factor
Environmental criteria are becoming increasingly important in carrier evaluation. CO2 emissions, fuel efficiency and sustainable means of transportation are integrated as additional KPIs in the performance evaluation and influence strategic decisions.
Conclusion
Carrier Performance is an indispensable tool for the strategic optimization of transport logistics. By systematically evaluating transport service providers, companies can reduce costs, improve delivery quality and minimize risks. The integration of modern technologies such as AI and IoT opens up new possibilities for more precise analyses and predictive optimization. However, successful implementation requires balanced KPI sets, reliable data quality and continuous development of evaluation methods.
FAQ
What is carrier performance and why is it important?
Carrier Performance is the systematic evaluation of the performance of transport service providers based on defined KPIs such as punctuality, quality and costs. It enables objective supplier selection, risk minimization and continuous optimization of logistics processes in the supply chain.
Which KPIs are most important for carrier performance?
The most important KPIs include on-time delivery rate (target value 95-99%), damage rate (below 0.5%), cost deviations (±3% tolerance) and response time in the event of problems (maximum 2 hours). These key figures should be measured regularly and summarized in weighted scorecards.
How often should Carrier Performance be evaluated?
A monthly evaluation is optimal for most companies, as it enables prompt reactions to performance deviations. Weekly reviews can be useful for critical transports or new carriers, while established partners can be evaluated on a quarterly basis.
What are the risks associated with carrier performance measurement?
The main risks are incomplete data quality, a one-sided focus on KPIs and a lack of carrier cooperation in the provision of data. These can be minimized through redundant data collection systems, balanced KPI sets and contractual transparency obligations.
.png)
.png)
.png)
